News networks need more presidential debate moderators who reflect America’s diversity

The presidential and vice presidential debates of 2024 feature only one journalist of color among six moderators, a failure of leadership that network news still has time to address.

Network news organizations have unprecedented scope to shape these debates, after both campaigns decided to bypass the Commission on Presidential Debates. Despite having talented, expert journalists of color on their staff, CNN, ABC and CBS have not yet used the opportunity to put forward moderators who fully reflect the nation the candidates are competing to represent.

The moderators selected thus far are all excellent journalists, but having a variety of backgrounds represented results in higher-quality journalism. The perspectives and experiences of journalists of color can ensure they pose questions that resonate with broader audiences. Instead, network and cable news networks are implicitly signaling that when the stakes are highest, white journalists are most likely to get the call.

There is still time to remedy the situation. ABC News, which is hosting the next presidential debate on Sept. 10, and CBS News, which is hosting the VP candidates on Oct. 1, can each add an additional moderator, as networks did during primary debates. They can also structure the debates to ensure candidates get questions from diverse audience members, including local journalists.

If an additional debate is held in October, as the Harris campaign has said is possible, the network that hosts the debate should ensure the moderators reflect the diversity of the American people.

Latino, Black, Asian and Indigenous people represent close to 40% of the U.S. population; they will represent more than half of the U.S. population by 2050 or so. This year, 36 million Latinos are eligible to vote, representing close to 15% of eligible voters. There are more than 34 million eligible Black voters and 15 million eligible Asian American voters.

Journalists of color don’t just pose good questions, they model participation in democracy for millions of young people who see them on the screen, people whose votes the candidates are working to earn. Asians and Latinos are the fastest-growing ethnic groups in America.

Yet this election cycle, the news networks appear to be moving backward. In 2020, Asian American journalist Elaine Quijano moderated the vice presidential debate, after Amna Nawaz, who is Asian American and Muslim, moderated a Democratic presidential primary debate.

So far this year, ABC News’ Linsey Davis, who is Black, is the only non-white moderator out of the six selected. The CNN presidential debate on June 27 was hosted by Dana Bash and Jake Tapper. ABC News says Davis and David Muir will moderate the next presidential debate. CBS says the vice presidential debate will be moderated by Norah O’Donnell and Margaret Brennan.

ABOUT THE ASIAN AMERICAN JOURNALISTS ASSOCIATION

The Asian American Journalists Association is a professional membership association founded in 1981. Since its founding, AAJA has been at the forefront of change in the journalism industry, advocating for accurate, comprehensive and fair coverage of the AAPI community. We champion the development of AAPI representation and leadership in journalism through trainings, opportunities and resources for our members as well as through nurturing and maintaining a network and community of AAPI journalists globally. Learn more at www.aaja.org or follow us on Twitter @AAJA.

ABOUT THE INDIGENOUS JOURNALISTS ASSOCIATION

The Indigenous Journalists Association’s mission is centered on the idea that accurate and contextual reporting about Indigenous people and communities is necessary to overcome biases and stereotypes portrayed in popular and mainstream media. Expanding access to accurate news and information is essential to an informed citizenry and healthy democracy, across tribal, local, state and national levels. Through programs that support diversity and defend free press, IJA promotes accurate media coverage and encourages all newsrooms to maintain the highest ethical standards when reporting on Indigenous communities. Learn more at indigenousjournalists.org and follow us on X @IndigenousJA.

ABOUT THE NATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF HISPANIC JOURNALISTS

The National Association of Hispanic Journalists is an educational and charitable association dedicated to the recognition and professional advancement of Hispanic students, professionals, and educators in the field of journalism. NAHJ focuses heavily on advocacy, addressing injustices and political issues that affect Latino journalists throughout the country, while also supporting a growing network of members and chapters. For more information please visit NAHJ.org or follow us on X @NAHJ.

You Might Also Like